Assessing ranked set sampling and ancillary data to improve fruit load estimates in peach orchards
Uribeetxebarria Alonso de Armiño, Asier
MetadataShow full item record
Fruit load estimation at plot level before harvest is a key issue in fruit growing. To face this challenge, two sampling methods to estimate fruit load in a peach tree orchard were compared: simple random sampling (SRS) and ranked set sampling (RSS). The study was carried out in a peach orchard (Prunus persica cv. 'Platycarpa') covering a total area of 2.24 ha. Having previously sampled the plot systematically to cover the entire area (104 individual trees or sampling points), both sampling methods (SRS and RSS) were tested by taking samples from this population with varying sample sizes from N = 4 to N = 12. Since RSS requires ancillary information to obtain the samples (ranking mechanism), several proximal and remote sensors already used or recently introduced in agriculture were assessed as data sources. A total of 14 variables provided by 5 different sensors and platforms were considered as potential ancillary variables. Among them, RGB images captured by an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV), and used to estimate the canopy projected area of individual trees, proved to be the best of the options. This was shown by the high correlation (R = 0.85) between this area and the fruit load, providing RSS with the UAV-based canopy projected area the lowest Coefficient of Error (CE) for a given tree sample size. Then, comparing relative efficiency between random sampling (SRS) and RSS, the latter enables more precise fruit load estimates for any of the considered sample sizes. Interest and opportunity of RSS can be raised from two points of view. In terms of confidence, RSS managed to reduce the variance of fruit load estimates by about half compared to SRS. Sampling errors above the 10% threshold were always produced significantly fewer times using RSS, regardless of the sample size. In terms of operation within the plot, sample size could be reduced by 50%, from N = 10 for SRS to N = 5 for RSS, and this being expected sampling errors less than 10% in practically 70% of the samplings performed in both cases. In summary, fruit growers can take advantage of the combined use of appropriate data (RGB images from UAV) and RSS to optimize sample sizes and operational sampling costs in fruit growing.
Is part ofComputers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2019, vol. 164, num. 104931
European research projects
The following license files are associated with this item:
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Stratified sampling in fruit orchards using cluster-based ancillary information maps: a comparative analysis to improve yield and quality estimates Uribeetxebarria Alonso de Armiño, Asier; Martínez Casasnovas, José Antonio; Escolà i Agustí, Alexandre; Rosell Polo, Joan Ramon; Arnó Satorra, Jaume (Springer, 2019-03-25)Estimation of yield or other fruit quality parameter is of great interest to farmers to decide on management actions just before harvesting and, in any case, to anticipate and plan harvesting operations. Making accurate ...
Comparing efficiency of different sampling schemes to estimate yield and quality parameters in fruit orchards Arnó Satorra, Jaume; Martínez Casasnovas, José Antonio; Uribeetxebarria Alonso de Armiño, Asier; Escolà i Agustí, Alexandre; Rosell Polo, Joan Ramon (The Animal Consortium, 2017-07-16)Different sampling schemes were tested to estimate yield (kg/tree), fruit firmness (kg) and the refractometric index (°Baumé) in a peach orchard. In contrast to simple random sampling (SRS), the use of auxiliary information ...
Combined use of remote sensing and soil sensors to detect variability in orchards with previous changes in land use and landforms: consequences for management Martínez Casasnovas, José Antonio; Daniele, Elisa; Uribeetxebarria Alonso de Armiño, Asier; Escolà i Agustí, Alexandre; Rosell Polo, Joan Ramon; Sartori, Luigi; Arnó Satorra, Jaume (The Animal Consortium, 2017-07-16)The present work investigated the application of detailed airborne images and a resistivity soil sensor (Veris 3100) to detect soil and crop spatial variability to assist in orchard management. The research was carried out ...