Bed load bias: Comparison of measurements obtained using two (76 and 152 mm) Helley‐Smith samplers in a gravel bed river
MetadataShow full item record
We assess how the size of the Helley‐Smith (HS) bed load sampler nozzle affects the accuracy of bed load sampling. Semitheoretical considerations show that the larger grains resident on the streambed can influence the sample either by blocking the sampler entrance or by causing the sampler to rest in a “perched” position. Probabilities for interference can be derived from the distribution of grain sizes but they do not capture the actual complexity of the influence of the bed on sampler performance. We therefore make an empirical comparison of sediment trapped by HS samplers with 76‐ and 152‐mm intakes during floods in the gravel bed lower Ebro River. Most bed load rates appeared higher when sampled with the HS152. The largest clasts collected by the HS76 also tend to be smaller than those obtained with the HS152 at the same flow. Analyzing paired bed load samples, we find the probability of a bed load sample collected with the HS152 to be biased is around 43% in the conditions of the present study, whereas 65% of samples were biased when obtained with the HS76. The analysis emphasizes the influence of bed material texture over sampler performance and demonstrates that the use of samplers with intake size much larger than bed grain size (i.e., ∼5D) will increase the accuracy of bed load grain size distributions and the precision of annual load estimates in gravel bed rivers.
Is part ofWater Resources Research, 2006, vol. 42, núm. 1, W01402
European research projects
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Vericat Querol, Damià; Batalla, Ramon J.; Gibbins, Chris N. (American Geophysical Union, 2008)This paper presents the results of experiments in which a portable flume was used to manipulate hydraulic conditions and create bed load transport in a gravel bed river. Flume data are coupled with those from Helley‐Smith ...
Evaluation of bed load transport formulae in a large regulated gravel bed river: The lower Ebro (NE Iberian Peninsula) López Alonso, Raúl; Vericat Querol, Damià; Batalla, Ramon J. (Elsevier, 2014-03-14)This paper tests the predictive power of 10 bed load formulae against bed load rates obtained for a large regulated river (River Ebro) the armor layer of which is subject to repeated cycles of break-up and reestablishment. ...
Influences of catchment and river channel characteristics on the magnitude and dynamics of storage and re-suspension of fine sediments in river beds Park, Jungsu; Batalla, Ramon J.; Birgand, François; Esteves, Michel; Gentile, Francesco; Harrington, Joseph R.; Navratil, Oldrich; López Tarazón, José Andrés; Vericat Querol, Damià (MDPI, 2019-04-26)Fine particles or sediments are one of the important variables that should be considered for the proper management of water quality and aquatic ecosystems. In the present study, the effect of catchment characteristics on ...