Improving the peer-review process and editorial quality: key errors escaping the review and editorial process in top scientific journals
MetadataShow full item record
We apply a novel mistake index to assess trends in the proportion of corrections published between 1993 and 2014 in Nature, Science and PNAS. The index revealed a progressive increase in the proportion of corrections published in these three highquality journals. The index appears to be independent of the journal impact factor or the number of items published, as suggested by a comparative analyses among 16 top scientific journals of different impact factors and disciplines. A more detailed analysis suggests that the trend in the time-to-correction increased significantly over time and also differed among journals (Nature 233 days; Science 136 days; PNAS 232 days). A detailed review of 1,428 errors showed that 60% of corrections were related to figures, authors, references or results. According to the three categories established, 34.7% of the corrections were considered mild, 47.7% moderate and 17.6% severe, also differing among journals. Errors occurring during the printing process were responsible for 5% of corrections in Nature, 3% in Science and 18% in PNAS. The measurement of the temporal trends in the quality of scientific manuscripts can assist editors and reviewers in identifying the most common mistakes, increasing the rigor of peer-review and improving the quality of published scientific manuscripts.
Is part ofPeerJ, 2016, vol. 4, e1670
European research projects
The following license files are associated with this item:
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as cc-by (c) Margalida, Antoni et al., 2016
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Improving the management procedures in farms infected with the Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome virus using PDP models Colomer, M. Àngels (Maria Àngels); Margalida, Antoni; Fraile Sauce, Lorenzo José (Springer Nature Publishing AG, 2019)Pig meat production need to be built up in the future due to the increase of the human population worldwide. To address this challenge, there is plenty of room for improvement in terms of pig production efficiency that ...
Population Dynamics P system (PDP) models: a standarized protocol for describing and applying novel bio-inspires computing tools Colomer, M. Àngels (Maria Àngels); Margalida, Antoni; Pérez Jiménez, Mario de Jesús (Public Library of Science (PLoS), 2013)Today, the volume of data and knowledge of processes necessitates more complex models that integrate all available information. This handicap has been solved thanks to the technological advances in both software and hardware. ...
Assessing the impact of removal scenarios on population viability of a threatened, long-lived avian scavenger Margalida, Antoni; Colomer, M. Àngels (Maria Àngels); Oro, Daniel; Arlettaz, Raphaël; Donázar, José A. (Nature Publishing Group, 2015)The removal of eggs or chicks from wild populations to create captive populations, reinforce free-ranging populations or reintroduce species into the wild is a restoration tool that requires an assessment of potential ...